Brightkite’s Check.In Misses the Poi.nt

brightkitelogo
Once again the good folks of Brightkite have missed the boat with their latest effort: Check.in.

The mobile site (not an app) gives a user the ability to simultaneously check in to up to three services: Brightkite, Foursquare and Gowalla.

It's a mobile app versus device app

It's a mobile app versus device app

It’s not all bad, they did bring a much needed search function to Gowalla, but the flow is a tad labored. It feels like there is an extra step.

Gowalla doesn't have search yet, so this is an advantage

Gowalla doesn't have search yet, so this is an advantage

It might not be fair to judge yet because it’s just a beta, but I couldn’t give a mayorship at Chuck E. Cheese. This is what I do.The fun of checking in is the PCP. That’s the post checkin page, not a hallucinogen. The PCP gives you tips, tells you if you’ve found an item, scored points, joined a society or become the mayor of a location. Brightkite has always been a slot machine without a jackpot.

This "are you sure" step is weird.

This "are you sure" step is weird.

The following URLs Weren’t Available?

  • Friendster2.com
  • No.fun
  • Despera.te
Hooray! Wait, that's it?

Hooray! Wait, that's it?

The Point of Checkins

Brightkite. Listen. You don’t get it. We checkin not only to tell our friends where we are, but to see what is happening at places and to see what happens next. You do a great job of showing people what is happening with your pictures feature, but you do not give people incentives, particularly with this app. No mayor? No items? That’s just plain lame and even if you intend to add the PCP later, you have done yourselves a disservice but releasing this beta without them. I’m calling callcheck.in http://dont.get.it.

In summary in an effort to save people time, Brightkite is actually creating a fun vaccuum. I would not waste your time with Check.in.

What do you think?

  • Wow, ok I see your points and raise you a mayorship. Check.in is in beta and they have allowed foursquare users to see who's the mayor at a location after you have checked in, via the updated version.

    I really get your point and agree about the tips. Using location-based services like foursquare AND others are really valuable to a user after a person checks in and it's not all about just checking in. But... there's another user base that I "think" check.in is going after. The users who wants to check-in to multiple service and save time while doing so. I timed myself checking in one time and it took me 2:15 secs to check into 7 different apps. Now I can check into 5 apps in about 30secs. From there if I choose to see what others are doing or what's nearby byl just launching one of the apps I checked into.

    Also the demand for apps like check.in were starting to get high and I wish I had it before SXSW. So if the app was going to be built, why not have it built by one of the existing location-based apps that has been around for a while... Brightkite.

    I truly think we're just seeing the beginning of check.in and the launch similar services. You have to admit it's off to a good start and using html5 is smart therefor making it available on any mobile device.
blog comments powered by Disqus